Friday, August 20, 2010

Perceptions of perceptions about America

Over the last couple of days there seems to be an emerging theme among blogs I am reading... a perception among Americans that the world looks not as highly upon America as it once did. Or at least those who matter to American self-esteem... meaning, mostly, Europe... don't think as highly of America as they once did.

I'd like to share a thought on that, as someone who admires America but is not American.

"Why'd we go save their asses from Hitler...??" ... I've read or heard, so many times.

Allow me to be a little blunt about this... that conceit doesn't go over well.

America's home cities were never subjected to devastating air strikes. Its farmlands never churned up under the wheels of ravenous armies (since the Civil War...). Its minorities never taken away to death camps. Its civilians never raped on mass or subjected to reprisals.
Others got the broken end of that bottle. Britain and the rest of the Commonwealth were at war for over two years before Pearl Harbor. Furthermore it was not only America that swung the balance... it was also the Russians - who lost more people than anyone else, who were labouring under an oppressive regime of their own, and which front swallowed as much as three quarters of the German war machine. Enough with "we saved your asses".
America would NOT have liked the rest of the world sealed shut inside the Third Reich, Stalin's Soviet Union and the Japanese Empire. I would have been a new dark age for America as well.

But history rolls on and when you have half the world tied up in a nuclear stand-off with an adversarial economic system like Soviet-style communism, and you have near total economic hegemony, and things at home are pretty cool and carefree... you can assume the rest of world thinks you're as glamorous as you do.

When the Soviets are gone but you still have everything else, you look for farcical pseudo-threats like "trade wars".

But when there is no Cold War narrative left ongoing, the economy is shaky and you have an atrocity like 9/11 to contend with... "carefree" goes right out the window.

When the central narrative of American politics becomes "what is America becoming?", all those quaint foreigners who you helped in some war long ago suddenly have opinions that seem to matter, because where else are you going to look for comparisons?

When Obama was elected president the world didn't celebrate because he was a black guy. They celebrated because they believed he was better for America. That a McCain-Palin administration would have been a freak show and driven the US economy off a cliff. They still believe that. It's still true. It wasn't just the promise of what Obama might represent as the crawling dread of what the alternative would have meant.

Reactionary Americans, which takes in most of the Right-wing blogosphere, still don't give a damn what the anyone thinks. If the solutions don't fit some mythic idea of what America is, was, or is remembered (often wrongly) to be... then those solutions are of no use to them.

The rest of the world has not changed its opinion of America. It is still greatly admired for what it does well.
I'm starting to think though, that Americans have become more aware of what the rest of the world thinks.

6 comments:

  1. Pretty good observations...

    I was living in Germany during the 50th anniversary of the end of WW II, and the constant obligatory thanking from European officials to Americans at every event got old and uncomfortable in a hurry. Even Germans who liked the US and had many Yank friends were increasingly rankled by it all. I bought beers when I could and told my German friends I was getting tired of it all as well.

    On one hand, I don't give a shit what others think, but I also think we as a nation do a very poor job of cultural outreach from our embassies and consulates.

    We do come in for some legitimate criticism, but much of it is unfounded or due to misperception fostered by people who really do hate us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes a lot of criticism is not justified.

    Bush and co made the potential for it worse by their take it or leave it, with-us-or-against-us stance.

    I remember the intensity of sympathy for America when 9/11 happened. At that moment a lot of the world felt profound unity with the US, but it was as if no-one in the White House gave a crap either way.

    Didn't know you lived in Germany...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was stationed there when I was still in the Air Force.

    "Bush and co made the potential for it worse by their take it or leave it, with-us-or-against-us stance.

    I'm going to shock you by agreeing with you. Just because you can doesn't mean you should.

    American can do much alone (or almost, with Britain and Australia and Canada) but we all pay a political price for it.

    I think our cause was noble in Iraq and Afghanistan, but going it alone with everyone against you will eventually sap the effort.

    The other side of that coin, waiting for grand consensus, means Iranians get nukes, Lebanon is swallowed by illiberal forces, and hundreds of thousands are slaughtered, raped and starved out in Darfur.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not of the opinion the true aims of the invasion of Iraq were pure and noble. Not at all.

    But other than that your points are good ones Silverfiddle.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In the long run it's probably unfortunate that we didn't get our noses bloodied in foreign wars. Success leads to hubris and that's the empire killer.

    Very nice post and good luck in putting the best political folks into office on your side of the world.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's never a good thing to have suffered.

    When 9/11 happened my fear was not so much what others might do to America as what America might do to itself. 9 years later it's still an open wound, oozing fear and prejudice. And ground zero is still a void, in more ones than one.

    Thanks for the wish of luck. It's a bit of a motley crew in our politics at the moment. Gillard is/was/is? a good prime minister. Unfortunately her position was bedeviled by bigger problems. Either the Coalition or the ALP could form a minority government over the next fortnight. Just have to wait and see. Truth be told the difference between them is not as great as between your major parties, so the country goes on business as usual.
    Maybe that's a good thing and maybe it isn't.

    ReplyDelete